Incineration vs Composting: Why US Livestock Producers Are Choosing Onsite Incineration
Discover why US livestock producers are choosing onsite incineration over composting. Compare biosecurity, operating costs and AIS concrete-lined incinerators.

Improving Farm Biosecurity, Reducing Mortality Disposal Costs and Increasing Operational Efficiency
Managing livestock mortality is one of the most important challenges facing agricultural producers across the United States.
For pig farms, poultry operations and large-scale livestock facilities, the method used to dispose of animal mortality has a direct impact on farm biosecurity, operating costs, labour requirements and overall efficiency.
For many years, composting has been a widely used method of managing animal mortality across the US agricultural industry. However, as producers place greater emphasis on disease prevention, operational efficiency and long-term cost control, many are considering the advantages of onsite incineration.
At Agri Incineration Systems (AIS), we manufacture high-performance, concrete-lined agricultural incinerators designed to provide US livestock producers with an efficient, reliable and biosecure mortality disposal solution. With 40 years of experience, AIS Cyclone incinerators feature monolithic concrete construction and come with a standard three-year warranty. Learn more about our US manufacturing.
But how does incineration compare with traditional composting, and what are the real benefits for modern farming operations?
1. The Hidden Costs of Livestock Composting
Composting is often considered a relatively inexpensive method of disposing of livestock mortality.
However, while the initial investment may be lower than purchasing an incinerator, there are several ongoing costs that producers must consider.
Effective mortality composting requires substantial quantities of carbon-rich material, such as:
- Sawdust
- Wood chips
- Straw
- Corn stalks
- Other suitable organic materials
These materials help manage moisture, support microbial activity and maintain the conditions necessary for decomposition.
How Much Composting Material Does a Farm Need?
The quantity of carbon material required depends on the type of livestock, carcass size, material selection and composting system.
For illustration, consider a farming operation using four pounds of carbon material for every pound of livestock mortality.
| Livestock mortality | Additional carbon material |
|---|---|
| 1,000 lbs | 4,000 lbs |
| 5,000 lbs | 20,000 lbs |
| 10,000 lbs | 40,000 lbs |
| 50,000 lbs | 200,000 lbs |
| 100,000 lbs | 400,000 lbs |
These figures illustrate a 4:1 mass ratio. Actual composting requirements should be determined using appropriate agricultural guidance and the specific materials being used.
For operations generating significant mortality volumes, sourcing, transporting, storing and managing this material can become a substantial ongoing expense.
With onsite incineration, livestock producers eliminate the need to purchase and manage carbon material specifically for mortality composting.
2. Composting Requires Significant Farm Space
One of the most frequently overlooked considerations when evaluating composting is the amount of space required.
Livestock composting requires suitable areas for:
- Storing carbon-rich material.
- Constructing compost piles or windrows.
- Managing primary decomposition.
- Completing secondary composting and curing.
- Handling and storing finished compost.
The required area increases with mortality volume and the amount of material being processed.
In comparison, an AIS agricultural incinerator provides a compact, purpose-built mortality disposal system.
Rather than dedicating significant areas of the farm to composting operations, producers can process mortality through an enclosed combustion chamber.
This can help improve:
- Site organisation.
- Operational efficiency.
- Machinery access.
- Available farm space.
- Overall mortality management.
For large pig production sites, particularly those operating multiple facilities, these benefits can be especially valuable.

3. Biosecurity: One of the Biggest Advantages of Incineration
Disease prevention is a major priority for the US livestock industry.
With ongoing concerns surrounding diseases such as African Swine Fever (ASF), Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome (PRRS) and avian influenza, maintaining effective biosecurity protocols is essential.
Mortality management is an important part of these protocols.
The Biosecurity Challenges of Composting
When properly managed, composting can be an effective method of reducing pathogens in animal mortality.
However, the process relies on achieving and maintaining appropriate temperatures throughout the composting material.
If temperatures, moisture levels or pile management are inadequate, there is a risk that decomposition and pathogen reduction will be incomplete.
Potential concerns include:
- Wildlife and scavenger access.
- Rodent activity.
- Exposed animal remains.
- Inadequate composting temperatures.
- Movement of potentially contaminated machinery.
- Increased handling of mortality.
- Additional vehicle movements associated with material deliveries and compost management.
The USDA recognises the importance of managing composting conditions and preventing environmental contamination, scavenger access and disease transmission.
How AIS Incineration Helps Protect Your Farm
Onsite incineration provides a controlled, high-temperature method of processing livestock mortality.
AIS incinerators are designed with primary and secondary combustion chambers to support effective combustion and help control emissions.
By processing animal mortality within an enclosed system, producers can significantly reduce exposure to wildlife, scavengers and other potential contamination pathways.
Key benefits include:
- High-temperature destruction of animal remains.
- Reduced handling of mortality.
- Reduced exposure to wildlife and scavengers.
- Less reliance on external carbon material deliveries.
- A controlled onsite disposal process.
- Reduced movement of potentially contaminated materials around the farm.
An important biosecurity principle is reducing unnecessary movement onto and around livestock facilities.
By eliminating the need for routine deliveries of composting material, onsite incineration can support stricter farm biosecurity procedures.
4. How Long Does Livestock Composting Take?
One of the biggest differences between composting and incineration is the time required to process livestock mortality.
Depending on carcass size, environmental conditions and composting practices, livestock composting can take several weeks to several months.
Guidance from the University of Minnesota Extension indicates that finishing-pig carcass composting can take approximately three to five months when primary composting, secondary composting and curing are considered.
Larger carcasses may require longer processing periods.
During this time, the composting area must be managed and monitored to ensure appropriate decomposition conditions.
The AIS Advantage: Faster Mortality Processing
Incineration offers a much faster method of processing mortality once a burn cycle begins.
Instead of waiting weeks or months for decomposition, producers can process livestock mortality through controlled combustion, reducing the remains to ash and non-combustible residue.
Depending on the incinerator model, load size, moisture content and operating conditions, this process can take a matter of hours.
This allows producers to manage mortality through a more predictable disposal schedule.
For modern commercial livestock operations, the ability to process mortality efficiently can be a significant operational advantage.

5. The True Cost of Composting: A 5,000-Sow Farm Example
To understand the potential scale of composting operations, consider a large US sow farm.
For this example, we will use the following assumptions:
- 5,000 sows.
- 14.3% annual sow mortality.
- Average mortality weight of 400 lbs.
- Illustrative carbon material requirement of 4 lbs per 1 lb of mortality.
Annual Mortality Calculation
5,000 sows x 14.3% mortality = 715 sows annually.
715 sows x 400 lbs = 286,000 lbs of annual mortality.
Carbon Material Requirements
Using the illustrative 4:1 ratio:
286,000 lbs x 4 = 1,144,000 lbs of additional carbon material annually.
If each delivery truck carries approximately 52,500 lbs of material:
1,144,000 / 52,500 = 21.79 truckloads.
In practical terms, this represents approximately 22 full truckloads of carbon material every year.
And that is before considering:
- Purchasing the material.
- Delivery and transportation costs.
- Storage requirements.
- Labour and machinery.
- Compost pile construction.
- Turning and monitoring.
- Handling the finished compost.
Actual material volumes and delivery requirements will vary depending on the carbon source, its bulk density and the composting method.
What Could Onsite Incineration Save?
With an AIS incinerator, producers can eliminate the need for carbon material used specifically for mortality composting.
The ongoing operating costs of incineration are primarily associated with fuel, electricity, maintenance and labour. AIS offers incinerator servicing and ongoing engineering support, and we also provide maintenance and technical support for incinerators manufactured by other brands.
Although incineration requires an initial equipment investment, the potential savings in material purchases, transport, handling and labour make it worth evaluating.
For larger farming operations, the benefits can become even more significant when assessed across multiple production sites.
6. Choosing the Right AIS Incinerator for Your Operation
Selecting the correct incinerator is essential to achieving efficient, cost-effective mortality disposal.
At AIS, we work with producers to assess several key considerations.
Load Capacity
The maximum amount of mortality that can be safely loaded into the incinerator.
Burn Rate
The amount of material the incinerator can process per hour under appropriate operating conditions.
Mortality Volume
The amount of mortality generated daily, weekly and annually.
Burn Frequency
How frequently the incinerator will need to operate to meet the site's disposal requirements.
Fuel Source
The availability and cost of diesel, LPG or natural gas.
Biosecurity Requirements
The farm's specific requirements for mortality handling, storage and disposal.
Correct equipment sizing helps producers achieve efficient operation while avoiding unnecessary fuel consumption and excessive operating times. AIS offers swine incinerators, poultry incinerators and other animal incinerators, including dead animal incinerator solutions, selected around each operation's requirements.

7. Real-World Example: A 4,400-Head Wean-to-Finish Pig Farm
Consider a US wean-to-finish pig operation with a capacity of 4,400 animals.
Using an illustrative mortality rate of 6.87% and 2.2 production cycles annually:
| Calculation | Estimated result |
|---|---|
| Site capacity | 4,400 pigs |
| Mortality rate per cycle | 6.87% |
| Mortalities per cycle | 302 pigs |
| Production cycles annually | 2.2 |
| Annual mortalities | Approximately 665 pigs |
For this example, assume that 60% of mortality occurs before pigs reach 80 lbs, with an average mortality weight of 35 lbs during this early period.
This produces approximately 6,348 lbs of mortality over the first 55 days.
The average is approximately 115 lbs of mortality per day during this period.
These are illustrative planning assumptions rather than universal US industry mortality rates. Actual mortality volumes and weights should be calculated using each farm's production records.
How the AIS 025 Cyclone Could Support This Operation
The AIS 025 Cyclone is designed for smaller agricultural operations requiring reliable onsite mortality disposal.
Key specifications include:
| Specification | AIS 025 Cyclone |
|---|---|
| Maximum load capacity | 551 lbs / 250 kg |
| Maximum burn rate | 110 lbs/hour / 50 kg/hour |
| Construction | Monolithic cast-concrete lining |
| Combustion system | Primary and secondary chambers |
| Fuel options | Diesel, LPG or natural gas |
Using an example load of approximately 462 lbs, a burn rate of 110 lbs/hour gives an estimated active processing time of 4.2 hours at maximum rated throughput.
Actual operation may take longer depending on the waste type, moisture content, loading conditions, warm-up and burnout requirements.
AIS's published technical documentation lists estimated diesel consumption of approximately 1.8-2.7 US gallons per hour during the main burn phase.
Using the theoretical 4.2-hour processing period, this equates to approximately 7.6-11.3 US gallons of diesel during the main burn phase.
Total fuel consumption per cycle will depend on actual burner operation, site conditions and the complete combustion cycle.
The correct burn schedule must also take account of permitted mortality storage periods, biosecurity requirements and applicable state regulations.
This example illustrates how matching incinerator capacity to farm mortality levels can create a more predictable and manageable disposal process.
Planning Onsite Incineration for Your Farm
Every operation generates mortality differently, and the right machine depends on your volumes, site layout and working routine rather than a single headline figure.
AIS supplies concrete-lined incinerators to US livestock producers and works with each customer on sizing, installation and ongoing support.
Want to compare composting with onsite incineration for your own mortality volumes? Contact Agri Incineration Systems with your livestock numbers, approximate daily mortality and current disposal method, and our team can help you assess a suitable Cyclone system.
